Sat Aug 24, 2013 3:04 pm
First make sure the raw footage is really uncompressed. BMDPCC is to have compressed raw so there is no point to compress it further. Images compress truly lossless only to ca 2:1 ratio. Such can be "mathematically" lossless, meaning the string of digits will reverse perfectly while uncompressing. Digital Betacam has this kind of compression if I remember correctly. RED on the other hand compresses raw in a lossy Redcode manner. They call it "visually lossless" but this is just an euphemism for a good , yet lossy compression. Alexa has a truly lossless raw. The idea behind raw is that it's a perfect archival format for bayer array derived images.
Debayering algorithms improve all the time and old raw images can only get better. Any lossy compression will negate this feature. So best is to leave raw--raw, as it came from the camera.
PS. Cineform is 3.5:1 to 10:1 so it's definitely a lossy codec.
Last edited by
nugat on Sat Aug 24, 2013 4:55 pm, edited 1 time in total.