Page 1 of 1

Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Mon May 27, 2019 2:01 am
by ravirai
I upgraded to the DaVinci Resolve Studio's update last Wednesday. I also upgraded my nVidia drivers to the latest one. Still keep seeing the "GPU memory full" error even with just 22 seconds of a 4k timeline. I have CUDA selected in GPU preferences.

Also, I am running a system with
Core i7 8700 CPU
GTX 1070 8GB VRAM
32 GB DDR4
Windows 10 x64

It's really frustrating and even the 4k playback wasn't that great and caused this to appear frequently. I had to then Generate Optimized media but overall, I still keep getting this annoying error.
Anyone know the permanent fix to this? I shouldn't have upgraded Resolve so soon.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Mon May 27, 2019 2:07 am
by Peter Chamberlain
Please specify the version of the GPU driver you are using. Latest isn't guidance for us.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Mon May 27, 2019 2:30 am
by ravirai
Peter Chamberlain wrote:Please specify the version of the GPU driver you are using. Latest isn't guidance for us.


Sorry, my bad. Driver version 430.64 from NVidia. Thanks.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Mon May 27, 2019 10:03 pm
by ravirai
Anyone have any solution to this? Or is it best for me to just revert to v15? Sorry, just bumping the post up at the same time too with this reply.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Tue May 28, 2019 11:04 am
by Gernot Grupe
ravirai wrote:Anyone have any solution to this? Or is it best for me to just revert to v15? Sorry, just bumping the post up at the same time too with this reply.


I have the same problem!
Do not waste your time! Install the version 15 parallel to the version 16! I hope you still have a database backup version 15!
Install version 15 in a separate directory, then import your database backup version 15.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Tue May 28, 2019 9:11 pm
by ravirai
Gernot Grupe wrote:
ravirai wrote:Anyone have any solution to this? Or is it best for me to just revert to v15? Sorry, just bumping the post up at the same time too with this reply.


I have the same problem!
Do not waste your time! Install the version 15 parallel to the version 16! I hope you still have a database backup version 15!
Install version 15 in a separate directory, then import your database backup version 15.


Oh my goodness, it looks like this is going to be a lesson learned the hard way for me. I got no database backup.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Wed May 29, 2019 11:11 am
by Steve Alexander
See the other thread discussing the latest 430.86 U3 driver 'Studio' version (apparently 'Studio' - available for GeForce / Titan cards (not Quadro) - is customized to work better with applications such as Resolve 16 - they actually mention Resolve 16). Some users report improvements.

Others report that they do not see improvements. In my opinion, BMD has dropped the ball on this one. They haven't acknowledged (that I'm aware of) that a GPU memory issue exists, regardless of the culprit. Hopefully this will be resolved shortly as it makes beta testing difficult for those working with Fusion inside Resolve 16.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Wed May 29, 2019 4:43 pm
by ravirai
Steve Alexander wrote:See the other thread discussing the latest 430.86 U3 driver 'Studio' version (apparently 'Studio' - available for GeForce / Titan cards (not Quadro) - is customized to work better with applications such as Resolve 16 - they actually mention Resolve 16). Some users report improvements.

Others report that they do not see improvements. In my opinion, BMD has dropped the ball on this one. They haven't acknowledged (that I'm aware of) that a GPU memory issue exists, regardless of the culprit. Hopefully this will be resolved shortly as it makes beta testing difficult for those working with Fusion inside Resolve 16.


Thank you! I do see NVidia's page mentions Resolve 16. I will download these drivers and hope that it works for me. I do hope they acknowledge this GPU memory issue and fix it before Resolve comes out of Beta.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Thu May 30, 2019 4:13 am
by ravirai
Just an update. For me, it did not work. The studio version upgrade of NVidia drivers. I still get the GPU memory full error. I think I am going to just wait till this is out of Beta. I've tried a lot of things suggested online. None seemed to have worked for me.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Thu May 30, 2019 4:36 pm
by Steve Alexander
Hi Ravi - what are you doing in Resolve when you get the GPU memory full error? Is it a complex timeline with Fusion effects? Is there any way someone else can try to reproduce your particular media, timeline resolution, effects, etc.?

I see it's a 22 second 4K timeline, but what else is going on there?

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Thu May 30, 2019 8:19 pm
by ravirai
Steve Alexander wrote:Hi Ravi - what are you doing in Resolve when you get the GPU memory full error? Is it a complex timeline with Fusion effects? Is there any way someone else can try to reproduce your particular media, timeline resolution, effects, etc.?

I see it's a 22 second 4K timeline, but what else is going on there?


Hey Steve, there are two PNG images, more than 10,000 res. That is really it. I am trying to render this with a little animation and it happens. Even on another timeline where I had all 4k clips, about a minute and 20 seconds or so in runtime, it happens sometimes right when I go to colour page, or sometimes just when playing it on timeline. And I am running all of this from Samsung 860 EVO SSD.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Fri May 31, 2019 1:41 pm
by Steve Alexander
I had something similar with large images in Fusion (page). I'll have to find some large images to test.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Fri May 31, 2019 2:33 pm
by Wandema
Had constant GPU memory full errors. Switched to latest NVIDEA drivers 430.86 and nailed to CUDA and manual GPU selection (only one GTX 1080 TI) and errors are gone.
Observed while rendering a timeline heavy CPU load (80-100%) and very little GPU use (10-18%). :ugeek:
I thought this should be the other way around...?
Cheers

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Fri May 31, 2019 4:15 pm
by Steve Alexander
OK - so I grabbed 4 5472x3648 JPG images from a DSLR and did the following:

1. New project
2. Imported the 4 images on the media page
3. Created a new 10 second Fusion Composition (29.97 fps)
4. Dragged the Fusion Composition to the timeline (default timeline was 1080p @ 24 fps)
5. Switch to the Fusion tab
6. Selected all 4 images and dragged them into the Fusion workarea
7. 4 Media In nodes were created (one for each image) and linked together with merge nodes
8. Selected the last in merge node in the change and pressed the 2 key to display its contents in the second viewer

BAM - GPU memory full message (peaking out at 8 GB for my P4000 card running the 430.86 drivers for Quadro - not the 'Studio' driver).

So this is interesting - scaling of large (certainly not huge) images consumes a huge amount of GPU memory....

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Fri May 31, 2019 6:54 pm
by Steve Alexander
Stripped this down to a single image in the Fusion composition - still got the GPU full error, after which - hang, crash...

edit - this is unusable. I need to reduce the size of the images to make this work.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Fri May 31, 2019 10:51 pm
by ravirai
Steve Alexander wrote:Stripped this down to a single image in the Fusion composition - still got the GPU full error, after which - hang, crash...

edit - this is unusable. I need to reduce the size of the images to make this work.


Yes, that's unacceptable though. I mean, just an image of more than 4k equivalent res shouldn't bring it down to its knees.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Thu Jun 06, 2019 4:26 am
by GrantRobertson
Yup, I figured I would go straight to the DR 16 beta for my first installation. I was thinking that my laptop was just too underpowered for this program until I saw this thread. I uninstalled 16 beta and installed DR 15.3 and it works great. I'll just have to wait for that "Cut" page.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Thu Jun 06, 2019 3:54 pm
by Richard Berg
So this is interesting - scaling of large (certainly not huge) images consumes a huge amount of GPU memory....

This has been an issue since at least Resolve 13. I've long been in the habit of using Irfanview to resize images to my timeline resolution before importing. Which is a shame, because it limits Resolve's ability to zoom & pan w/o lost fidelity.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Sat Jun 08, 2019 3:27 am
by Peter Chamberlain
Richard Berg wrote:
So this is interesting - scaling of large (certainly not huge) images consumes a huge amount of GPU memory....

This has been an issue since at least Resolve 13. I've long been in the habit of using Irfanview to resize images to my timeline resolution before importing. Which is a shame, because it limits Resolve's ability to zoom & pan w/o lost fidelity.


We have customers using 9k source images so it’s likely you system that’s the limit but without further info its hard to advise.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error - except I'm not now

PostPosted: Sat Jun 08, 2019 9:08 am
by jameshcox
Hi.

Just in case this helps anyone else; I'm no longer seeing this problem.

I have a slightly different use-case to the one described here: I'm simply assembling video clips in a 4k timeline with colour correction and some power windows with tracking. Until now I was regularly getting GPU memory full errors though.

I changed to:
  • Resolve 16 Beta 4
  • Nvidia studio driver 430.86
I've not had a GPU memory full error since that change.

Computer is a DELL XPS 15, 16gb, Intel Core i7, with a built-in GTX 1050 GPU.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error - except I'm not now

PostPosted: Sat Jun 08, 2019 9:42 am
by Duke Sweden
jameshcox wrote:Hi.

Just in case this helps anyone else; I'm no longer seeing this problem.

I have a slightly different use-case to the one described here: I'm simply assembling video clips in a 4k timeline with colour correction and some power windows with tracking. Until now I was regularly getting GPU memory full errors though.

I changed to:
  • Resolve 16 Beta 4
  • Nvidia studio driver 430.86
I've not had a GPU memory full error since that change.

Computer is a DELL XPS 15, 16gb, Intel Core i7, with a built-in GTX 1050 GPU.

Same here! Your post could have been written by me except for my GPU being a 1050ti. Just did one of my admittedly small projects from start to finish with no GPU Memory Full errors. In fact have not had any errors at all, even adjustment layer worked great whereas before it would freak out my source monitor and then crash. Running like a finished product right now.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Sat Jun 08, 2019 10:23 am
by Jean Claude
ravirai wrote:I upgraded to the DaVinci Resolve Studio's update last Wednesday. I also upgraded my nVidia drivers to the latest one. Still keep seeing the "GPU memory full" error even with just 22 seconds of a 4k timeline. I have CUDA selected in GPU preferences.

Also, I am running a system with
Core i7 8700 CPU
GTX 1070 8GB VRAM
32 GB DDR4
Windows 10 x64

It's really frustrating and even the 4k playback wasn't that great and caused this to appear frequently. I had to then Generate Optimized media but overall, I still keep getting this annoying error.
Anyone know the permanent fix to this? I shouldn't have upgraded Resolve so soon.


Hello,

If it does not work with images of 10 000px with gtx 1070 8Gb VRAM there must be an issue with the drivers or PC configuration, sorry.

Davinci Resolve Beta 4 is capable of processing images of over 7680 x 4320 px => 33 177 600 px in color tab or fusion + blur ...in a 8K TL

Color_33177600px.jpg

Fusion_33177600px.jpg


(thanks for seeing the "Memory Used")

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Sat Jun 08, 2019 11:03 am
by Steve Alexander
Peter Chamberlain wrote:
Richard Berg wrote:
So this is interesting - scaling of large (certainly not huge) images consumes a huge amount of GPU memory....

This has been an issue since at least Resolve 13. I've long been in the habit of using Irfanview to resize images to my timeline resolution before importing. Which is a shame, because it limits Resolve's ability to zoom & pan w/o lost fidelity.


We have customers using 9k source images so it’s likely you system that’s the limit but without further info its hard to advise.


Hi Peter -

I noticed the massive consumption of GPU memory by placing a single 5600 X 3800 (approx) JPG image in a 10 sec Fusion comp - project timeline was 1080p24. I merged the JPG with a background node and then played the result to cache on the fusion page. I watched the GPU memory rise to close to the 8 GB available. I then switched back to the edit page and the fusion comp began to render and that's when the GPU memory full message appeared. This can't be right.

Since that original post I have upgraded to the studio driver 430.86 (on Resolve beta 3) and there was an improvement - no GPU full messages but several crashes). Since then two things have changed on my system. I'm now running Windows 10 Pro 1903 and Resolve 16 beta 4. Have not yet seen a GPU memory full message and no crashes.

So it appears that somewhere between bugs in the drivers and bugs in Resolve 16, there have been complimentary improvements. More testing to do and evidently not everyone is enjoying the same success.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Sat Jun 08, 2019 11:26 am
by Duke Sweden
Jean Claude wrote:
ravirai wrote:I upgraded to the DaVinci Resolve Studio's update last Wednesday. I also upgraded my nVidia drivers to the latest one. Still keep seeing the "GPU memory full" error even with just 22 seconds of a 4k timeline. I have CUDA selected in GPU preferences.

Also, I am running a system with
Core i7 8700 CPU
GTX 1070 8GB VRAM
32 GB DDR4
Windows 10 x64

It's really frustrating and even the 4k playback wasn't that great and caused this to appear frequently. I had to then Generate Optimized media but overall, I still keep getting this annoying error.
Anyone know the permanent fix to this? I shouldn't have upgraded Resolve so soon.


Hello,

If it does not work with images of 10 000px with gtx 1070 8Gb VRAM there must be an issue with the drivers or PC configuration, sorry.

Davinci Resolve Beta 4 is capable of processing images of over 7680 x 4320 px => 33 177 600 px in color tab or fusion + blur ...in a 8K TL


His original post was put up on May 28th, before beta 4 was released.

Re: Still having GPU memory full error

PostPosted: Sat Jun 08, 2019 12:10 pm
by Steve Alexander
So as I continue to play with Resolve 16 (now beta 4) I can repeatedly get it to fail with a GPU-related error (usually error 79 as reported by a dialog box) - sometimes it just hangs and I need to force close.

Here are the steps if BMD is interested.

Bring in several JPG images and then composite them together (see attached image). As you add more of these together (you can see I have 3 images) but if I add a fourth and then comp with a mask, Resolve runs into a problem.

Notice that the image size (all the same) are not all that large. The project timeline that these sit on is 1080p.

Even with the comp below, if you play the comp on the Fusion page, I get a GPU error. I have the 430.86 Studio drivers installed.

resolve_large_image_fusion_comp.png
resolve_large_image_fusion_comp.png (960.63 KiB) Viewed 5966 times