- Posts: 17
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2017 7:09 pm
Hi,
a friend just bought the Intensity Shuttle and this is how it came to my attention. But I just don't get, which problem it tries to solve.
I suspect it's just outside of my usual workflow: I get footage after the shoot (in best quality possible) and then grade it in Resolve and then convert it for web (h264, youtube, vimeo), a fullrange master in dnxhd for archive and sometimes make a dvd für a TV station (the last one I made 4 years ago...)
Does the Intentsity Shuttle help me somehow with this task? I have a windows workstation with gtx 970 and connected via displayport 4k AdobeRGB monitor calibrated to rec709 or sRGB.
Stuff I think I groked:
My questions
So what the shuttle does, it makes it possible to take an ordinary FullHD TV, connect it (e.g. via HDMI ) to the PC and then I get a accurate rec709 output to grade in Resolve? Is that right?
I won't have to calibrate that TV separately, because the shuttle outputs a standardized 10bit hd output, which then the TV can bring into whichever colorspace it want. for e.g if I use a factory rec709 calibrated flanders, I will then have accurate rec709 colors.
But this doesn't work with the resolve preview viewer, because it's not designed for this?
but the shuttle has now way to know the colors on the TV are accurately displayed without feedback/calibration? so I need a factory calibrated monitor for this (e.g. a rec709 calibrated review monitor)
What if I need 4k, do I just need to buy a more expensive version?
Does this help me, if I almost never grade for TV, only for web and it looks the same there as on my monitor? And almost no consumer has a calibrated monitor anyway?
Ok, I stop asking questions now, I think there must be a point that I completely missed or I just don't have the problem it tries to solve?
a friend just bought the Intensity Shuttle and this is how it came to my attention. But I just don't get, which problem it tries to solve.
I suspect it's just outside of my usual workflow: I get footage after the shoot (in best quality possible) and then grade it in Resolve and then convert it for web (h264, youtube, vimeo), a fullrange master in dnxhd for archive and sometimes make a dvd für a TV station (the last one I made 4 years ago...)
Does the Intentsity Shuttle help me somehow with this task? I have a windows workstation with gtx 970 and connected via displayport 4k AdobeRGB monitor calibrated to rec709 or sRGB.
Stuff I think I groked:
- Sometimes there are different blacks between PP, FCP and Resolve, but you can solve it with attention to details (data levels in output and clip attributes)
- It's not possible to use 10bit output on windows 10 via a consumer graphic card (if at all)
- When you export to h264 there is a slight color shift to magenta compared to the preview window in resolve, which people often try to make the preview window responsible for not accurately displaying rec709, but I found the shift doesn't happen if you export to dnxhd and also happens if you export from e.g. premiere pro another source. so the shuttle won't help in this case, especially if it's the codec.
- So the preview window is not accurately displaying rec709, there are some workarounds, but they are not perfect. But even then, if you render to h264 it will look different anyway
My questions
So what the shuttle does, it makes it possible to take an ordinary FullHD TV, connect it (e.g. via HDMI ) to the PC and then I get a accurate rec709 output to grade in Resolve? Is that right?
I won't have to calibrate that TV separately, because the shuttle outputs a standardized 10bit hd output, which then the TV can bring into whichever colorspace it want. for e.g if I use a factory rec709 calibrated flanders, I will then have accurate rec709 colors.
But this doesn't work with the resolve preview viewer, because it's not designed for this?
but the shuttle has now way to know the colors on the TV are accurately displayed without feedback/calibration? so I need a factory calibrated monitor for this (e.g. a rec709 calibrated review monitor)
What if I need 4k, do I just need to buy a more expensive version?
Does this help me, if I almost never grade for TV, only for web and it looks the same there as on my monitor? And almost no consumer has a calibrated monitor anyway?
Ok, I stop asking questions now, I think there must be a point that I completely missed or I just don't have the problem it tries to solve?
System Specs:
MB: ASrock extreme 4 z370
CPU: i7-i8700k
RAM: 32GB
GPU: Nvidia GTX 970 4GB
Storage(main): 1TB Sandisk SSD
Win 10 Pro
MB: ASrock extreme 4 z370
CPU: i7-i8700k
RAM: 32GB
GPU: Nvidia GTX 970 4GB
Storage(main): 1TB Sandisk SSD
Win 10 Pro