Wed Feb 10, 2021 4:02 pm
Reviving this old thread as I am revisiting this question once again.
I ended up upgrading to the Quad 2 which is a great card for my DIT work at a very reasonable price point.
I am predominantly using it for Livegrading using Pomfort Livegrade.
Pomfort have enabled VANC metadata capture via BMD cards so I can gather important information from Arri Cameras via SDI, however those same Arri Cameras use HANC for their record start stop flag and it would be great to be able to make use of this and automatically record whenever we roll a take. Something that other manufacturers capture cards do support.
Similarly to Roger Godspeed I would also want to receive the filename from RED cameras.
With many digital cinema cameras metadata and record flags can be in either section of the ancillary metadata, either HANC or VANC depending on the choices of the manufacturer and their other camera metadata is also spread between the two. The main cameras I tend to come across in Livegrading come from Arri (the many flavours of Alexas and the Amira), Sony (Venice, F65) and RED.
Simply having support for access to both sections of ancillary data in the SDK would really help with this situation, allowing full metadata support for the SDI output of all relevant cameras to be developed by software partners and make the Quad 2 the best choice for Livegrading multi-camera shows. As it is, it's a compromise and those who place more importance on the auto record and metadata gathering facilities will choose cards by other manufacturers that support those features.
I'm sure those operating Video Playback via QTake would also appreciate the option to buy BMD cards without this compromise - they make even heavier use of auto record and SDI record flags and filename metadata than I do in LiveGrading. (This is all relevant to the high end commercials, Features and TV drama market.)
Since I use Resolve on set in the same setup I chose BMD cards because those are the only ones supported by Resolve. However it would be great if this situation didn't feel like a compromise forced on me!