Adam Langdon wrote:With the release of the Komodo X claiming an extra stop in the shadows, I’d love to see how the 12K OPLF stacks up against the KX.
I haven't used the KX but I have used the original Komodo a bunch.
I think they're totally different use cameras. It's hard to compare them really. One is a global shutter, the other is a totally unique RGBWWW sensor.
Let's start with the good. A lot of the good is also bad for me but here goes...
ProsGlobal shutter (a killer feature if you need it)
Box shape
80FPS@6K
Locking RF mount
Current best media (CFe)
Good off-camera control with networking (and wifi)
Integrated battery
ConsBox Shape (Terrible for anything but gimbal use)
Only 80FPS @6K (120 FPS@8K for 12k)
Only locking RF mount means you have to use an adaptor for anything else.
Integrated Vlock battery only. Once you use a larger battery or want to use your AB then you're into a kludge of adaptors.
For one thing, you can't really trust the DR claims RED make. All manufacturers are optimistic when they post about DR except for Arri but RED are especially so. You really can't believe anything that's claimed till you can actually shoot and compare.
I've also found that Komodo is AT BEST iso800, but it really wants to be shot a lot lower. I was shooting a show with DXL2 as the principal camera, and Komodo really struggled to keep up in terms of ISO. Obviously haven't shot KX yet so not sure what it's sweet spot will be.
Komodo is a box shape with the same terrible screen pointing at the SKY that's only good at best for camera settings (if you have good eyesight to read their tiny text on screen). It still only has a single SDI output, something that a lot of red users had been hoping wouldn't be the case again as there are many examples where the single SDI port on Komodo has failed and there's no easy way to work with your camera when that happens. At least they made it so you can direct connect a RED touch screen, a massive failing on the OG Komodo.
I just think you don't really use a Komodo or a 12K UMP in the same situations. They are targeting quite different users...
I think Komodo is a camera that at least is unique and offers options you can't get with anything else. For all the RED tactical machismo and the user base that goes with that, Komodo (and x) is the only camera they've made that actually gets close to their original brand promise.
JB