What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

Get answers to your questions about color grading, editing and finishing with DaVinci Resolve.
  • Author
  • Message
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostSat May 02, 2020 8:11 pm

Both cards in. Starting out with force reboot of monitor after black screen but pc started normally during black screen. After driver install full system freeze force reboot. No picture during boot force monitor reboot. Standard driver settings both GPUs are used 5-70% . 4K very loud . I do not care about the noise :-) stability number, one performance number 2 ..... noise number 10.:-)

Result is ........ 1201

This was with latest drivers

Latest result: details

CPU: AMD Ryzen Threadripper 3960X 24-Core Processor
GPU: NVIDIA GeForce RTX 2080 SUPER (26.21.14.4292)
RAM: 64GB
Storage: Force MP600 (X:)~NVMe Samsung SSD 970 SCSI Disk Device (C:)~ST4000LM024-2AN17V (Y:)
OS Version: Windows 10 Pro (Ver. 1909)
----------

Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K,Overall Score,1007,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K Test Average,Basic Grade,155.4,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K Test Average,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,80.1,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K Test Average,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,82.9,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K Test Average,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,43.9,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K Test Average,Optimized Media,141.1,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K CinemaRAW Light,Codec Average,79,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,Codec Average,99.9,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 422,Codec Average,116.4,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 4444,Codec Average,113.7,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K RED,Codec Average,94.5,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K CinemaRAW Light,Basic Grade,54.91,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K CinemaRAW Light,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,14.18,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K CinemaRAW Light,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,13.33,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K CinemaRAW Light,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,0,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K CinemaRAW Light,Optimized Media,102.08,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,Basic Grade,77.65,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,14.99,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,15.32,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,0,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,Optimized Media,143.11,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 422,Basic Grade,92.57,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 422,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,15.99,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 422,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,16.17,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 422,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,5.98,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 422,Optimized Media,218.45,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 4444,Basic Grade,45.63,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 4444,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,15.14,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 4444,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,14.25,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 4444,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,5.74,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 4444,Optimized Media,150.69,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K RED,Basic Grade,33.09,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K RED,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,12.08,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K RED,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,10.66,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K RED,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,4.96,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K RED,Optimized Media,42.29,FPS


-----System Specs-----
Computer Name: SYLVESTCORP
CPU: AMD Ryzen Threadripper 3960X 24-Core Processor
GPU: AMD Radeon VII (26.20.15029.27016)~AMD Radeon VII (26.20.15029.27016)
RAM: 64GB
Storage: Force MP600 (X:)~NVMe Samsung SSD 970 SCSI Disk Device (C:)~ST4000LM024-2AN17V (Y:)
OS Version: Windows 10 Pro (Ver. 1909)
----------

Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K,Overall Score,1201,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K Test Average,Basic Grade,153,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K Test Average,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,155.4,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K Test Average,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,115.3,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K Test Average,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,64.4,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K Test Average,Optimized Media,112.4,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K CinemaRAW Light,Codec Average,67.9,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,Codec Average,119.4,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 422,Codec Average,128.9,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 4444,Codec Average,137.4,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K RED,Codec Average,147,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K CinemaRAW Light,Basic Grade,25.86,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K CinemaRAW Light,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,19.05,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K CinemaRAW Light,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,14.25,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K CinemaRAW Light,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,0,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K CinemaRAW Light,Optimized Media,79.73,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,Basic Grade,75.60,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,31.91,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,24.38,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,0,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,Optimized Media,119.48,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 422,Basic Grade,84.46,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 422,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,30.54,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 422,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,24.36,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 422,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,9.11,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 422,Optimized Media,114.72,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 4444,Basic Grade,49.59,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 4444,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,30.55,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 4444,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,20.55,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 4444,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,8.33,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K ProRes 4444,Optimized Media,92.59,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K RED,Basic Grade,47.15,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K RED,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,27.00,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K RED,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,14.84,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K RED,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,7.06,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.1.17),4K RED,Optimized Media,58.68,FPS


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostSat May 02, 2020 9:08 pm

The dual Radeon VII have improved stability in resolve :-) but for me the rtx 2080 is faster because of the h.265 hw encode decoder.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Offline

MishaEngel

  • Posts: 1300
  • Joined: Wed Aug 29, 2018 12:18 am
  • Real Name: Misha Engel

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostSat May 02, 2020 11:54 pm

SylvestCorp wrote:The dual Radeon VII have improved stability in resolve :-) but for me the rtx 2080 is faster because of the h.265 hw encode decoder.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


To bad all h.265 hw encoders produce medio core quality compared to software encoders.
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostSun May 03, 2020 7:26 am

MishaEngel wrote:
SylvestCorp wrote:The dual Radeon VII have improved stability in resolve :-) but for me the rtx 2080 is faster because of the h.265 hw encode decoder.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


To bad all h.265 hw encoders produce medio core quality compared to software encoders.
100% Agree the difference huge. :-) quality of the hw encoder is just taking too many shortcuts.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostSun May 03, 2020 8:42 am

Quick test youtube 4k quicktime simple cut and run :-) dual Radeon vii on gopro h.265 to a ram disk.: mgpu set to on.
native h264 : 4.25 useless quality
Amd h254 : 5.33 useless quality
Amd h265 : 4.51 useless quality

Nvidia single card:
Native h264 : 4.19 useless quality
Nvidia h264 : 2.55 not too bad but not usable
Nvidia h265 : 3.38 not too bad but not usable

None of the renders are any good in the gray sky . Do not know why right now. Crap on crap ends up in crap :-)
A little confused they were SO bad.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Offline

Lucius Snow

  • Posts: 252
  • Joined: Sun Nov 24, 2013 1:19 pm

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostSun May 03, 2020 12:31 pm

SylvestCorp wrote:The dual Radeon VII have improved stability in resolve :-) but for me the rtx 2080 is faster because of the h.265 hw encode decoder.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Can you please give your results to the Candle Benchmark test (66 nodes) with your Dual Radeon VII in OpenCL?
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostSun May 03, 2020 7:21 pm

Lucius Snow wrote:
SylvestCorp wrote:The dual Radeon VII have improved stability in resolve :-) but for me the rtx 2080 is faster because of the h.265 hw encode decoder.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Can you please give your results to the Candle Benchmark test (66 nodes) with your Dual Radeon VII in OpenCL?
Ok I will see what I can do. Just running the h265 master full quality on the rtx there is only a nvidia option it is 20 cou% and 99 % GPU. Same clip super quality btw it is a 59,94 FPS. It took 4.24 min.

13 FPS on rtx 2080 super 66 nodes playback
I just linked and played no issues.

Dual Radeon VII 2 FPS at first restart very choppy playback I media.
Same result 2 frames playback 24 cores on 15% total util on cpu is 6%. The gpu are both 49-45% load.
Mgpu on off 3-4 frames. 66 nodes

Single gpu scope 14-15 FPS gpu up to 99% load. The other gpu is 6-13 %.
Changed the gpu to the other clean 14 FPS the non display card is 0% load. The primary card is 99% load 3685 mb of vram.

The Radeon skips frames in edit an trans edit modes.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostSun May 03, 2020 7:26 pm

I did a quick render out to what ever was there and one card was 7 sec and two was 34 sec


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Offline

Lucius Snow

  • Posts: 252
  • Joined: Sun Nov 24, 2013 1:19 pm

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostSun May 03, 2020 10:51 pm

So you have the same symptom as I described here:
https://forum.blackmagicdesign.com/viewtopic.php?f=21&t=107550
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostMon May 04, 2020 5:00 am

Lucius Snow wrote:So you have the same symptom as I described here:
https://forum.blackmagicdesign.com/viewtopic.php?f=21&t=107550
The problem is the work load distribution in e.g blender each cpu works on a seperate task. In Resolve they work on the same part together with a massive overhead through the pcie bus.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostMon May 04, 2020 5:10 am

The cards are not running full speed as they are waiting. Thats why the nvlink i nvidia quadro cards it a big thing.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostMon May 04, 2020 6:59 am

SylvestCorp wrote:The cards are not running full speed as they are waiting. Thats why the nvlink i nvidia quadro cards it a big thing.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
No more test from me :-) back on a single rtx 2080 super. Dreaming about a dual nvlink setup with titan rtx or V .


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Offline

Lucius Snow

  • Posts: 252
  • Joined: Sun Nov 24, 2013 1:19 pm

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostMon May 04, 2020 11:11 am

SylvestCorp wrote:
Lucius Snow wrote:So you have the same symptom as I described here:
https://forum.blackmagicdesign.com/viewtopic.php?f=21&t=107550
The problem is the work load distribution in e.g blender each cpu works on a seperate task. In Resolve they work on the same part together with a massive overhead through the pcie bus.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

The same Dual Radeon VII configuration on Metal give more than 24 fps (not 4 fps).
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostMon May 04, 2020 12:35 pm

Resolve should be able to devide the load then. There is no crossfire workload on mac So each gpu gets its own work unit mabe?
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostMon May 04, 2020 12:41 pm

Can you run Puget systems benchmark on the mac pro with dual radeons vii’s. Which CPU was used?
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostMon May 04, 2020 1:24 pm

Dual Radeon VII on metal =



Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostWed May 13, 2020 2:47 pm

The answer to this question is dual Radeon Pro VII with AMD Infinity Fabric. This is no joke just released from amd today.
Offline

MishaEngel

  • Posts: 1300
  • Joined: Wed Aug 29, 2018 12:18 am
  • Real Name: Misha Engel

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostWed May 13, 2020 3:02 pm

SylvestCorp wrote:The answer to this question is dual Radeon Pro VII with AMD Infinity Fabric. This is no joke just released from amd today.


Have fun testing the pro drivers on the cheap standard Radeon VII.
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostWed May 13, 2020 3:39 pm

No thanks i quit trying new drivers for the Readon VII. The dream some had about the Radeon VII can now rest.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostSat May 23, 2020 6:15 am

I tested the latest pro and gaming driver versions. They are/seem stabel and there is no black screens. Stilll no speed up with 2, but with 2 the load of the gpu is 10-30 % and very silent 26-80 watt.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostSat May 23, 2020 7:12 am

I set mgpu in driver and unticked det non display gpu in resolve and now candel mark jumped to 16 fps in deliver page from 2. Latest gaming driver: windows 10 pro!! can any one confirm this? the gpus, now goes to 99%.
Any one please test :-)
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostSat May 23, 2020 8:15 am

[quote="SylvestCorp"]Agree. My point is two radeon vii will never, except on mac, be a good solution since they made specific features for this in the pro version.

I was completly wrong !!!!!! latest gaming drivers mgpu set to on. In resolve deselect the none display card.
Could anyone confirm the Candelmark 15-17 FPS 66 nodes with dual "Radeon VII" some driver improvements have already helped the non pro card.

puget system benchmark results are absolutely massive:

[size=50]-----System Specs-----
Computer Name: SYLVESTCORP
CPU: AMD Ryzen Threadripper 3960X 24-Core Processor
GPU: AMD Radeon VII (26.20.15029.27016)~AMD Radeon VII (26.20.15029.27016)
RAM: 64GB
Storage: Force MP600 (X:)~NVMe Samsung SSD 970 SCSI Disk Device (C:)~ST4000LM024-2AN17V (Y:)
OS Version: Windows 10 Pro (Ver. 1909)
----------

Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K,Overall Score,1420,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K Test Average,Basic Grade,197.2,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K Test Average,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,117.4,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K Test Average,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,135.6,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K Test Average,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,72.8,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K Test Average,Optimized Media,187.1,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K CinemaRAW Light,Codec Average,106,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,Codec Average,125.1,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K ProRes 422,Codec Average,155.4,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K ProRes 4444,Codec Average,155.1,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K RED,Codec Average,168.5,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K CinemaRAW Light,Basic Grade,64.81,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K CinemaRAW Light,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,20.17,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K CinemaRAW Light,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,21.17,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K CinemaRAW Light,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,0,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K CinemaRAW Light,Optimized Media,128.63,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,Basic Grade,92.77,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,23.23,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,23.99,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,0,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K H264 150Mbps 8bit,Optimized Media,151.34,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K ProRes 422,Basic Grade,106.62,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K ProRes 422,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,24.82,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K ProRes 422,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,25.71,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K ProRes 422,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,9.54,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K ProRes 422,Optimized Media,260.95,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K ProRes 4444,Basic Grade,64.00,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K ProRes 4444,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,23.59,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K ProRes 4444,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,22.16,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K ProRes 4444,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,9.06,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K ProRes 4444,Optimized Media,143.70,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K RED,Basic Grade,46.47,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K RED,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,15.12,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K RED,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,20.00,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K RED,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,8.90,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),4K RED,Optimized Media,110.57,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K,Overall Score,1432,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K Test Average,Basic Grade,215,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K Test Average,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,127.8,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K Test Average,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,138.6,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K Test Average,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,59.5,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K Test Average,Optimized Media,175,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K H265 100Mbps to 8K,Codec Average,105.2,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K H265 100Mbps to UHD,Codec Average,109.6,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K RED to 8K,Codec Average,157.8,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K RED to UHD,Codec Average,200.2,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K H265 100Mbps to 8K,Basic Grade,35.63,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K H265 100Mbps to 8K,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,5.73,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K H265 100Mbps to 8K,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,7.72,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K H265 100Mbps to 8K,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,0,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K H265 100Mbps to 8K,Optimized Media,61.33,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K H265 100Mbps to UHD,Basic Grade,55.46,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K H265 100Mbps to UHD,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,22.88,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K H265 100Mbps to UHD,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,21.52,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K H265 100Mbps to UHD,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,8.91,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K H265 100Mbps to UHD,Optimized Media,61.31,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K RED to 8K,Basic Grade,25.54,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K RED to 8K,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,5.15,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K RED to 8K,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,7.25,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K RED to 8K,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,0,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K RED to 8K,Optimized Media,62.70,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K RED to UHD,Basic Grade,55.46,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K RED to UHD,OpenFX - Lens Flare + Tilt-Shift Blur + Sharpen,22.52,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K RED to UHD,Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,21.52,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K RED to UHD,3x Temporal NR - Better 2 Frames,8.91,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),8K RED to UHD,Optimized Media,62.70,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),Fusion,Overall Score,1296,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),Fusion Test Average,Score,129.6,Score
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),Fusion_3DBacklitText,Reference FPS,7.06,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),Fusion_PhoneComposite,Reference FPS,0,FPS
Puget Systems DaVinci Resolve Studio Benchmark V0.6 BETA (DR 16.2.2.11),Fusion_TurbulantParticles,Reference FPS,3.75,FPS
[/size]
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostSat May 23, 2020 8:20 am

Lucius Snow wrote:
SylvestCorp wrote:The dual Radeon VII have improved stability in resolve :-) but for me the rtx 2080 is faster because of the h.265 hw encode decoder.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Can you please give your results to the Candle Benchmark test (66 nodes) with your Dual Radeon VII in OpenCL?


I just ran with the latest driver 15-17 FPS latest resolve latest Radeon VII game drivers 2x Radeon VII. Can you confirm my results ? mgpu set to on and the non display card deselected in resolve.
Offline

Lucius Snow

  • Posts: 252
  • Joined: Sun Nov 24, 2013 1:19 pm

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostSat May 23, 2020 11:49 am

I already have 15 fps on the 66 node Benchmark test with the old 19.11.3 drivers on Windows. But with a single GPU enabled in Resolve only. Both enabled give 4 fps.

It's still very far from the results by Metal.
Offline

SylvestCorp

  • Posts: 87
  • Joined: Sat Feb 01, 2020 8:19 pm
  • Real Name: Hans Christian Sylvest

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostSat May 23, 2020 12:16 pm

I was just hopeing so much. Stability seem good.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Offline

Lucius Snow

  • Posts: 252
  • Joined: Sun Nov 24, 2013 1:19 pm

Re: What's the verdict on Radeon VII for Resolve?

PostSat May 23, 2020 2:28 pm

SylvestCorp wrote:I was just hopeing so much. Stability seem good.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

I reach 20 fps with both Radeon VII enabled on Linux.
Previous

Return to DaVinci Resolve

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: davidhdennis, roger.magnusson and 74 guests