- Posts: 2
- Joined: Tue May 10, 2022 3:38 pm
- Real Name: Martin Katrušák
Hello everyone, i try last few weeks find some good answers for me and for choosing new pc for BMD DR studio.
At first let me kindly thank you to all that will help and give me answers. Am sorry for english if i make some mistake, im writting from phone so some mistake can be here.. Also here are sources which i mainly make and do in DR:
-editing video in 1080p or 3840p timeline
-files are mostly from mirorless cameras Panasonic or Sony so video up to 6k 10bit 4:2:2- 90% of all time i can tell its 4k 25fps video from sony a7s3 with 10bit 422, and 4k 100fps at same 10bit ( sometimes i get few raw files from bmp 6k - but maybe once per year i have thoose files.)
-timeline is mostly under 10 minutes
-minimum fusion clips (95% are titles)
-coloring clips (with about 5-10 nodes)
Thoose are things i used to make 99% of time and i had for last 2 years HP OMEN 15.6" dh0107nc
I mostly of all above do coloring or correcting in color page, thats where i spent most of time. This is why i am looging for better screen, as you can see that HP OMEN have "on paper" 100%dci-p3 coverage.
I travell lot, I've also considered building a pc many times, but at the moment it still doesn't pay off for me. I don't have a monitor at home, maybe in time I'll buy it as a second monitor at home, but I'm still looking for a quality screen in my laptop.
The second main information is that apple isnt an option. I think about apple many times, and yes i do not have nothing bad with it, but lot of app i need to use are working only with Windows, and thats maybe why i am not able to take apple now. If I wasn't limited by windovs, I really like the new ones apple laptop versions. Unfortunately, as well as the "technician" who works with dji products, I must be able to have my ntb work with dji applications such as dji assistant and they only work on windows. Also i use dji terra which have acceleration for RTX cards only... so my choices are shrinking.
Actually on market HP isnt good in my opinion, qualitty is much worse than years ago. I am decideing to grab Dell or Asus or maybe Gygabite, if you should be able to help me.
Now, most models which i found to be really great for me, arent no longer at stock... (sad but true, trust me i search whole our market), i found model from ASUS : G533ZW-LN123W and G533QS-HQ221T (links will be in the end). Thoose two have 100% dci p3 screen and are new models with solid specs, but i am not really sure with build qualitty . Then i had my NO 1. which was dell: N-AWm15R5-N2-951K. Trust me or not, month back this ntb was able to buy and now dell isnt able to supply this model so its EOL. Last one opinion is Gigabyte: XE4-73EE614SH. . I do not have experience with this brand, but it looks like it have solid screen with calibration. So if someone have this model or know them, i would be glad for some feedback.
Now to my questions... I really have Dell as number 1. models i found which should be also good for me and are awalible to order are: N-G5521-N2-715K-US, N-AWm15R5-N2-752K - thoose two notebook should be maybe good for me at least for next year or two. BUT ! DELL claim that thoose two notebooks have 99% DCI-P3 coverage, and now i am not really sure if it should be good or not. In any cases i will calibrate monitor.
My two questions should be:
1, do you think that display that claim 99% dci-p3 which will be calibratet is still better than 100% dci-p3?
2, do you think AMD Ryzen R7 5800H and 3060 will be enought for at least 4k 10 bit "smooth" editing (it will suffice in half or quarter mode)?
Thanky ou all for helping me !
links (sorry i figure out that i cant post links, but when you type https://www it may work...) :
asus
G533ZW-LN123W- (here without www, just https://) rog.asus.com/cz/laptops/rog-strix/rog-strix-scar-15-2022-series/spec
G533QS-HQ221T- .jrc.cz/ASUS-ROG-Strix-SCAR-15-G533QS-HQ221T-cerny-p15469
Gigabyte
XE4-73EE614SH - .czc.cz/gigabyte-aero-5-xe4-intel-12th-gen-cerna/338000/produkt
Dell
N-AWm15R5-N2-951K - .czc.cz/alienware-m15-ryzen-editon-cerna_6/323283/produkt
N-G5521-N2-715K-US - .czc.cz/dell-15-g15-5521-special-edition-cerna_5/341919/produkt
N-AWm15R5-N2-752K - .czc.cz/alienware-m15-ryzen-editon-cerna_2/323282/produkt
At first let me kindly thank you to all that will help and give me answers. Am sorry for english if i make some mistake, im writting from phone so some mistake can be here.. Also here are sources which i mainly make and do in DR:
-editing video in 1080p or 3840p timeline
-files are mostly from mirorless cameras Panasonic or Sony so video up to 6k 10bit 4:2:2- 90% of all time i can tell its 4k 25fps video from sony a7s3 with 10bit 422, and 4k 100fps at same 10bit ( sometimes i get few raw files from bmp 6k - but maybe once per year i have thoose files.)
-timeline is mostly under 10 minutes
-minimum fusion clips (95% are titles)
-coloring clips (with about 5-10 nodes)
Thoose are things i used to make 99% of time and i had for last 2 years HP OMEN 15.6" dh0107nc
I mostly of all above do coloring or correcting in color page, thats where i spent most of time. This is why i am looging for better screen, as you can see that HP OMEN have "on paper" 100%dci-p3 coverage.
I travell lot, I've also considered building a pc many times, but at the moment it still doesn't pay off for me. I don't have a monitor at home, maybe in time I'll buy it as a second monitor at home, but I'm still looking for a quality screen in my laptop.
The second main information is that apple isnt an option. I think about apple many times, and yes i do not have nothing bad with it, but lot of app i need to use are working only with Windows, and thats maybe why i am not able to take apple now. If I wasn't limited by windovs, I really like the new ones apple laptop versions. Unfortunately, as well as the "technician" who works with dji products, I must be able to have my ntb work with dji applications such as dji assistant and they only work on windows. Also i use dji terra which have acceleration for RTX cards only... so my choices are shrinking.
Actually on market HP isnt good in my opinion, qualitty is much worse than years ago. I am decideing to grab Dell or Asus or maybe Gygabite, if you should be able to help me.
Now, most models which i found to be really great for me, arent no longer at stock... (sad but true, trust me i search whole our market), i found model from ASUS : G533ZW-LN123W and G533QS-HQ221T (links will be in the end). Thoose two have 100% dci p3 screen and are new models with solid specs, but i am not really sure with build qualitty . Then i had my NO 1. which was dell: N-AWm15R5-N2-951K. Trust me or not, month back this ntb was able to buy and now dell isnt able to supply this model so its EOL. Last one opinion is Gigabyte: XE4-73EE614SH. . I do not have experience with this brand, but it looks like it have solid screen with calibration. So if someone have this model or know them, i would be glad for some feedback.
Now to my questions... I really have Dell as number 1. models i found which should be also good for me and are awalible to order are: N-G5521-N2-715K-US, N-AWm15R5-N2-752K - thoose two notebook should be maybe good for me at least for next year or two. BUT ! DELL claim that thoose two notebooks have 99% DCI-P3 coverage, and now i am not really sure if it should be good or not. In any cases i will calibrate monitor.
My two questions should be:
1, do you think that display that claim 99% dci-p3 which will be calibratet is still better than 100% dci-p3?
2, do you think AMD Ryzen R7 5800H and 3060 will be enought for at least 4k 10 bit "smooth" editing (it will suffice in half or quarter mode)?
Thanky ou all for helping me !
links (sorry i figure out that i cant post links, but when you type https://www it may work...) :
asus
G533ZW-LN123W- (here without www, just https://) rog.asus.com/cz/laptops/rog-strix/rog-strix-scar-15-2022-series/spec
G533QS-HQ221T- .jrc.cz/ASUS-ROG-Strix-SCAR-15-G533QS-HQ221T-cerny-p15469
Gigabyte
XE4-73EE614SH - .czc.cz/gigabyte-aero-5-xe4-intel-12th-gen-cerna/338000/produkt
Dell
N-AWm15R5-N2-951K - .czc.cz/alienware-m15-ryzen-editon-cerna_6/323283/produkt
N-G5521-N2-715K-US - .czc.cz/dell-15-g15-5521-special-edition-cerna_5/341919/produkt
N-AWm15R5-N2-752K - .czc.cz/alienware-m15-ryzen-editon-cerna_2/323282/produkt