I would love to see a proper naming scheme for all the color spaces.
Preferably all the commonly used combined ones with a '/' to divide like most of them are.
For me the 'dummy proof' naming schemes create more confusion than clarity.
Project Settings Color Space List:
ACES -> AP0/Linear or ACES2065-1
ACEScc -> AP1/ACEScc
ACEScct -> AP1/ACEScct
ARRI LogC -> ARRI Wide Gamut/LogC or AWG/LogC
CST Color Space:
ACES -> ACES (AP0)
ARRI Alexa -> ARRI Wide Gamut
ACES Transform:
Alexa -> ARRI Wide Gamut/LogC or AWG/LogC
Add missing color space -> ACES2065-1
Remove all CSC labels on those color spaces and remove any duplicates.
RWG/Log3G10 is the same as RED Log3G10 REDWideGamutRGB - CSC
Initially the idea in the node was to only have Display targets as output spaces but in practice this is not the only task an ACES transform should do so CSC versions were added to both input and output lists but we really just need the actual to be the same on both sides. Make the input list equal to the output list!
This should also fix the sorting in alphabetical order so non display transforms (with - CSC at the end) are easily reachable like ACEScct which is probably used more often than the huge display list.
Alternatively you could split out these to ACES Display Transform and ACES Color Space Transform by having a setting inside the node to tell whether you want to go to display or not and thus changing the list accordingly to clean it up.
Curious how others feel about this.
Preferably all the commonly used combined ones with a '/' to divide like most of them are.
For me the 'dummy proof' naming schemes create more confusion than clarity.
Project Settings Color Space List:
ACES -> AP0/Linear or ACES2065-1
ACEScc -> AP1/ACEScc
ACEScct -> AP1/ACEScct
ARRI LogC -> ARRI Wide Gamut/LogC or AWG/LogC
CST Color Space:
ACES -> ACES (AP0)
ARRI Alexa -> ARRI Wide Gamut
ACES Transform:
Alexa -> ARRI Wide Gamut/LogC or AWG/LogC
Add missing color space -> ACES2065-1
Remove all CSC labels on those color spaces and remove any duplicates.
RWG/Log3G10 is the same as RED Log3G10 REDWideGamutRGB - CSC
Initially the idea in the node was to only have Display targets as output spaces but in practice this is not the only task an ACES transform should do so CSC versions were added to both input and output lists but we really just need the actual to be the same on both sides. Make the input list equal to the output list!
This should also fix the sorting in alphabetical order so non display transforms (with - CSC at the end) are easily reachable like ACEScct which is probably used more often than the huge display list.
Alternatively you could split out these to ACES Display Transform and ACES Color Space Transform by having a setting inside the node to tell whether you want to go to display or not and thus changing the list accordingly to clean it up.
Curious how others feel about this.
Last edited by shebbe on Fri Nov 26, 2021 4:35 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Home System Resolve 18.6b9: Z790 / i9 13900K / 64GB DDR5 / RTX4090 / Win 11 / ASUS PA32UGC 1600 nits
Office System Resolve 18.6b9: X570 / Ryzen 9 5900X / 128GB DDR4 / RTX4090 / Win 11 / EIZO CG248-K
Office System Resolve 18.6b9: X570 / Ryzen 9 5900X / 128GB DDR4 / RTX4090 / Win 11 / EIZO CG248-K