- Posts: 17
- Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2019 3:52 am
- Real Name: Mark Zeeter
A followup on the solution I achieved, mainly because I dislike finding a post from the past that has no answer.
Disclaimer: While I have a solution that works, I do not fully understand why it works. If anyone wants to fill in details that'd be great.
I posted this same issue on the AVSForum, where a respondent noted that as the ATEM output is YCbCr 4:2:2, and many devices that have an overlay function--like the Extron--convert to RGB, the issue being experienced as outlined in my original post was probably due to a color space swap happening.
I had a Decimator on hand that does color space conversions, so I updated my signal chain as follows:
ATEM Constellation HD M/E 2 multiview ---SDI --> BMD SDI-to-Optical ---Fiber--> BMD Optical-to-HDMI ---HDMI--> Decimator MD-HX ---HDMI--> Extron XTP T USW 103 4K
Using this setting on the Decimator, the image was perfect.
What I don't understand is why does this fix it? It seems like the conversion is changing the ATEM signal TO YCbCr. That seems backwards to me, unless I'm reading it wrong. Or is there a missing flag on the HDMI output of the Optical-to-HDMI Teranex that the Decimator is simply conforming correctly?
To finish the story, getting accurate color output from the Extron needed these settings:
(apologies for a picture of a screen)
To wit, I'm now seeing what I would expect:
(again, apologies for a picture of a screen)