Thu Feb 25, 2016 1:11 pm
Tom, I agree with a number of things you said. The number of product lines is staggering. There might be a bit of a negative in combining studio and cinema lines. I don't mind it, but some people might see it differently in studio. After the original BMD was released (I think first year) I saw some truely horrible footage on ABC 24. I suspect somehow somebody got the idea to somehow fit a feed from a camera. Don't know what brand of camera, but did not look like a studio camera. It bears no relation anyway, BMD studio cameras would be the real deal, but maybe there is some custom tunning apart from different sensor formats.
But just on the portable side there should be just a micro 4k, pocket 4k, mini and Ursa4.6-8k. Can the rest. If they can function as a modular part of the studio line good. As some people have worked out, a modular head can be inserted with a recording display unit on a gimbal (oh please) and off the gimbal as a picket. The same head can insert into a 10 inch studio feed unit, or a portable Ursa mini unit with semi auto set picture and lens control, and eng prosumer functions (oh please, there is such a big market), and even on the the Ursa. The problem is cooling and a better picture might require a head not so small. So you probably produce 4k, 4.6k heads (8k might just not be small enough on the technology used. There is technology that could do it (Nokia basically ran a 8k sensor binned years ago. Which is a long time in development time for the industry to develop 8k low cost, low heat video sensors, which we will probably see in coming years). The industries roll out of acceptable technology often lags the capability to do so. The first 8k camera was over 12 years ago. When they want to boost revenues, and by.the looks of it the cist comes way down, they can release it. We are talking.big players here, not BMD. You might wonder about past sensor sizes, well that is what xsn happen when you have to by pass industry sources to get parts, like scientific sensors etc. Personally, Aptiba had a nice 4k video ready at the time. The manufacturer of the J1 let slip that their camera's Aptina sensor was already 4k video capable, and that he was looking into doing it, from memory. Last I saw of that. JVC also revealed there old very cheap hybrid sports camcorder already had a 4k video capable sensor in it and they were going to release a new 4k model (if only). They even showed the existing camera outputing 4k video a few ces's ago from memory. Last I heard about that. We are lucky to have BMD try this for us, but those FPGAs are one thing I would love to see go. The only descent FPGA's I have heard of dissapeared to the military over ten years ago, I know, I wanted to get my hands on them for a product. I'd rather see them using the new Nividia rig. They are going to release a credit card sized drone board with artifical intelligence video analysis that virtually pulls in 8k worth of video data. That is the reality of where things are at the moment. That credit card sized drone board is practically a pocket sized camera heart, at 8k. FPGA, is a big clumsy, power hungry, hot if you want big performance stop gap measure. Asic chips are good if you have the volume, and Chios Luke the nvidias are good alternatives (I isolate them out because they have done a nice low powered design).
Denny, because of the pockets problems it definitely needs a new version. So it is probably.more likely to happen, or be dropped eventually. I like the pocket concept, however, they never gave even a 1080p48/50 sports mode, so it was a failure. If only they could have done that with semi auto in firmware, it would have been good. Now it is time for 4kp50 (last year 4k p24/25 as an early development compromise). But the sensor thing is the thing. I'm reasonably happy if p50 had been, or will be, prores only.
aIf you are not truthfully progressive, maybe you shouldn't say anything
bTruthful side topics in-line with or related to, the discussion accepted
cOften people deceive themselves so much they do not understand, even when the truth is explained to them