- Posts: 637
- Joined: Sun Nov 25, 2018 7:52 am
- Location: Castro Valley, CA
- Real Name: Donald Keller
I recently had the opportunity to shoot a scene with a Panasonic DC-S1H camera. In between takes I snapped some shots with my BMPCC 4K for comparison.
The DC-S1H was set to HD ProRes 422 10 Bit Long GOP 100Mbps and used Leica Summilux-M 1:1.4/35 mm ASPH ($5895), APO-Summicron-M 50mm f/2 ASPH ($8795) and 90mm f/2.0 APO Summicron-M ASPH ($5095) lenses through an adapter set to around F/5.6. I set the BMPCC4K to HD Blackmagic Raw 3.1 using Voightlander lenses set to F/0.095 to F/2.8 with Tiffen Variable ND and Hoya IR cut filters. We used some canned fog and I thought the wider aperture would not cut out the fog on the BMPCC 4K while utilising the Voightlander's flaring character.
This shot was into the sun at 10 AM, about 30 degrees above so I set the Voightlander 17.5mm to F/0.95 or F/1.4 at ISO 4000 or higher to prevent sillouetting. This increased the noise and in contrast the 14 stop dynamic range of the S1H helped it's image. The S1H with the Leica Summilux-M 1:1.4/35 mm ASPH is on the top and the BMPCC 4K is on the bottom with the Voightlander 17.5mm F/0.95. Scroll down on the image to see the comparison.
In this shot the S1H used a Leica APO-Summicron-M 50mm f/2 ASPH on the top and the BMPCC 4K used a Voightlander 25mm F/0.95 on the bottom at ISO 400. Scroll down on the image to see the comparison.
I didn't have time to focus the BMPCC 4K properly on this one, so it's a little soft since I focused on the chair before the actor sat in it. In this shot the S1H used a Leica 90mm f/2.0 APO Summicron-M ASPH on the top and the BMPCC 4K used a Voightlander 42.5mm F/0.95 at ISO 400 on the bottom. The depth of field was so small on this full frame camera four feet from the subject that when he tilted his head forward his ears were in focus, but his eyes looked soft. I had to back off and abandon the extreme close-up the director wanted to allow him to have freedom to act. A M4/3 camera would have a deeper depth of field.
Scroll down on the image to see the comparison.
Under the right conditions I am confident that the BMPCC 4K will make a good B camera to the S1H.
The guy who owned the Panasonic S1H camera dies at the end of the scene.
Were the results due to the camera or the lenses?
I'm going to go out and buy a lottery ticket. Once I get some of that good Leica glass, I'm going to demand a re-match!
The DC-S1H was set to HD ProRes 422 10 Bit Long GOP 100Mbps and used Leica Summilux-M 1:1.4/35 mm ASPH ($5895), APO-Summicron-M 50mm f/2 ASPH ($8795) and 90mm f/2.0 APO Summicron-M ASPH ($5095) lenses through an adapter set to around F/5.6. I set the BMPCC4K to HD Blackmagic Raw 3.1 using Voightlander lenses set to F/0.095 to F/2.8 with Tiffen Variable ND and Hoya IR cut filters. We used some canned fog and I thought the wider aperture would not cut out the fog on the BMPCC 4K while utilising the Voightlander's flaring character.
This shot was into the sun at 10 AM, about 30 degrees above so I set the Voightlander 17.5mm to F/0.95 or F/1.4 at ISO 4000 or higher to prevent sillouetting. This increased the noise and in contrast the 14 stop dynamic range of the S1H helped it's image. The S1H with the Leica Summilux-M 1:1.4/35 mm ASPH is on the top and the BMPCC 4K is on the bottom with the Voightlander 17.5mm F/0.95. Scroll down on the image to see the comparison.
- Panasonic S1H Top BMPCC 4K Bottom
- PanS1H_S1T2_184Top&P4KV17Br31S1_S028Bottom.png (725.95 KiB) Viewed 5332 times
In this shot the S1H used a Leica APO-Summicron-M 50mm f/2 ASPH on the top and the BMPCC 4K used a Voightlander 25mm F/0.95 on the bottom at ISO 400. Scroll down on the image to see the comparison.
- Panasonic S1H Top BMPCC 4K Bottom
- PanS1H_SI4T1_189Top&P4KV25Br31SI4_S040ABottom.png (618.87 KiB) Viewed 5332 times
I didn't have time to focus the BMPCC 4K properly on this one, so it's a little soft since I focused on the chair before the actor sat in it. In this shot the S1H used a Leica 90mm f/2.0 APO Summicron-M ASPH on the top and the BMPCC 4K used a Voightlander 42.5mm F/0.95 at ISO 400 on the bottom. The depth of field was so small on this full frame camera four feet from the subject that when he tilted his head forward his ears were in focus, but his eyes looked soft. I had to back off and abandon the extreme close-up the director wanted to allow him to have freedom to act. A M4/3 camera would have a deeper depth of field.
Scroll down on the image to see the comparison.
- Panasonic S1H Top BMPCC 4K Bottom
- PanS1H_S5BT2_198Top&P4KV42Br31S6_S047Bottom.png (657.46 KiB) Viewed 5332 times
Under the right conditions I am confident that the BMPCC 4K will make a good B camera to the S1H.
The guy who owned the Panasonic S1H camera dies at the end of the scene.
Were the results due to the camera or the lenses?
I'm going to go out and buy a lottery ticket. Once I get some of that good Leica glass, I'm going to demand a re-match!
Last edited by dondidnod on Sun Mar 15, 2020 10:20 pm, edited 1 time in total.